Everyone talks about Preston and Lochmere—and for good reason. These popular Cary neighborhoods are gorgeous, well-established, and full of charm. But if you’re only looking where everyone else is, you might miss out on some of the town’s hidden gems. Cary is packed with lesser-known neighborhoods that offer a fantastic lifestyle, often with a lower price tag, less competition, and just as much to love.
MacGregor Downs: Not Just for Golfers
Okay, maybe “underrated” is a stretch for locals in the know, but MacGregor Downs often flies under the radar with new buyers. Tucked alongside a private golf course and MacGregor Downs Lake, this neighborhood blends Southern elegance with quiet, tree-lined streets. Many of the homes were built in the ‘70s and ‘80s, giving the community a stately, well-rooted feel.
It’s not flashy or trendy, and that’s part of its appeal. You’ll find custom homes on large lots, top-ranked schools nearby, and a real sense of community. If you value character, privacy, and a central location, MacGregor Downs might just be your perfect fit.
Carpenter Village: Small-Town Feel, Big-Time Location
Carpenter Village has a vibe all its own. With charming architecture, walkable streets, and a community pool and lake, this neighborhood feels like its own little town. The homes range from townhouses to spacious single-family houses, which makes it popular with a wide variety of buyers, from young professionals to growing families.
It’s also incredibly convenient. You’re minutes from Research Triangle Park, RDU Airport, and all the shopping and dining options you could want. But the peaceful vibe of the neighborhood makes it feel miles away from the bustle. It’s a great blend of access and escape.
Cary Park: Community-Centered and Full of Life
Cary Park doesn’t always get the attention it deserves, but residents rave about its lifestyle. With a central lake, miles of greenway trails, and a mix of housing styles, it’s a community designed for connection. Whether you’re walking your dog, taking the kids to the playground, or grabbing coffee at the neighborhood shops, it’s easy to feel at home here.
This neighborhood is especially appealing to those who want newer homes with a modern feel but still value a tight-knit community. It’s close to great schools and has easy access to RTP and Chapel Hill, making it ideal for commuters.
Highcroft: A Hidden Gem With Serious Curb Appeal
Highcroft is one of those neighborhoods that people discover and fall in love with immediately. With its tree-lined streets, well-maintained homes, and quiet cul-de-sacs, it feels like the perfect suburban retreat. The community pool and clubhouse are big perks, and Highcroft Elementary is right in the heart of the neighborhood.
What sets it apart? The balance. It’s peaceful without feeling isolated and upscale without being out of reach. It’s a great option for buyers who want that “just right” blend of comfort, convenience, and charm.
Let Nina Gervase Help You Find Your Cary Gem
Whether you’re just starting your search or narrowing down the options, working with a local expert can make all the difference. Nina Gervase knows Cary inside and out—including the underrated neighborhoods most buyers overlook. If you’re ready to find the right home in a community you’ll love, get in touch with Nina today and start exploring all the hidden gems Cary has to offer.
